Alinsky Now
  • Home
  • Works/Faith
  • Craft
  • Organizers
  • Community Renewal
  • Legacy
    • Critics
  • Contact

Black Hole in Cyberspace 1

8/28/2013

1 Comment

 
Picture
Black Hole in Cyberspace  Part 1

Conventional wisdom has it that Industrial Areas Foundation (IAF) style face-to-face organizing is outdated and outmoded – a kind of political blast from the past.   The primary technologies invented by Saul Alinsky are now seen by many as quaint outcroppings of a now bygone era.  Today’s Alinskyites, according to this view, are building political ghost towns in desert wastelands far from the wellsprings of real power.   Short on scale, short on national reach, short on grand plans.  This is the critique delivered by a raft of politicians (including President Obama himself), academics, union leaders and political consultants.  

New modes of web based communication - faster, easier to scale, simpler to launch and subject to manipulation by a handful of super techies and their backers – are touted as a superior use of time, talent and money if change is the objective and utilitarian metrics the obsession.   Grand scale initiatives appealing to mega donors driven by the promise of big, fast change dwarf the slow, patient work of face-to-face organizing.

Modern political campaigns including the spectacular flare up of the first Obama campaign exemplify the high dollar, high tech approach to messaging, vote gathering and measured impact.  The fact that David Plouffe and company pursued the systemic integration of low tech “house meetings” to augment both the air and ground games of the first Obama campaign reflects the extent to which the imperial vision of candidate promotion digested face to face Alinskyite modalities for its own ends.  The house meetings served an important purpose of offering the appearance of attention and consultation to a voting population hungry for the touchstone of real engagement.  They also blipped upwards the high tech communications database and added bodies to the walks and talks of the ground game.

More sales event than real conversation the Plouffe/Obama approach betrayed the core value of the house meeting.  The campaign ended up compromising and trivializing the house meeting methodology even while succeeding at advancing an instrumental outcome – the election of Barack Obama.  From the point of view of political instrumentality these events were a grand success.  From the point of view of deepened democratic practice they were short term, shallow, deceptive and ultimately disheartening for legions of participants.

1 Comment
Redhead Escort Mission link
3/13/2025 03:42:37 pm

I find it encouraging that even high-tech campaigns recognize the value in face-to-face interaction.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Frank C. Pierson. Jr.

    Frank Pierson

    Frank Pierson is a leading authority on the life and legacy of Saul Alinsky.    He may be reached at [email protected] 

    Archives

    February 2015
    June 2014
    April 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013

    Categories

    All
    Charles Koch
    Collectivist
    Dixie Cups
    Friedrich Hayek
    Harry Reid
    IAF
    IAF Board
    Industrial Areas Foundation
    Saul Alinsky
    Schopenhauer

    Action
    Alinsky
    Alinskyites
    AT & T
    Barack Obama
    Business
    Campaign Metrics
    Central Planning
    Church Militant
    Commie Pinko
    Community Organizing
    David Plouffe
    Empowerment Zone
    Enterprise Zone
    Foundations
    Gamaliel
    Hillary Clinton
    House Meetings
    Iaf
    Industrial Areas Foundation
    Jewish Roots
    John Carson
    John Legere
    Local Ownership
    Michael Gecan
    MLK Day
    Non Partisan Politics
    Obama
    Organizer
    Organizing
    PCIC
    Peter Buffett
    Philanthropy
    Pico
    Pima County Interfaith Council
    Political Deception
    Politics
    Pope Francis
    Progressive
    Promise Zone
    Prophetic Acts
    Ralph Benko
    Re Imagining Community Organization
    Re-imagining Community Organization
    Right Wing Nuts
    Saul Alinsky
    Stephanie Block
    The Blaze
    T Mobile
    Warren Buffett

    RSS Feed

HOME | WORKS/FAITH | CRAFT | RENEWAL | ORGANIZERS |  LEGACY |  CONTACT 
Picture
© Alinsky Now | All Rights Reserved, 2022